Recipe

The Best Lime Ice Cream

Community Pick!

The Best Lime Ice Cream

Photo by Sarah Shatz

  • Chef

    merrill's Notes: It's funny how often there are early indications of the profession a child will pursue as an adult. According to my mother, there were more than a few telltale signs during my youth suggesting...

    Expand

Makes about 3 cups

3/4 cups white sugar Ask the
hotline about
this ingredient!

1 1/2 cup heavy cream Ask the
hotline about
this ingredient!

2 tablespoons grated lime zest Ask the
hotline about
this ingredient!

1/3 cup lime juice (Key lime juice is great if you can bear squeezing all those little guys) Ask the
hotline about
this ingredient!

  1. Combine all of the ingredients, stirring until the sugar is dissolved.

    Ask the hotline about this step!
  2. Freeze in an ice cream maker, or in a wide, shallow container, stirring from time to time. Devour! Note: Don't be dismayed if the ice cream never gets really hard in your freezer -- the texture should be airy and light.

    Ask the hotline about this step!
Epietzsch Reply

We brought this recipe to the beach! We bought an ice cream maker yesterday and made this last night! We all agree that it is the best ever:) we're going to try the genius river cafe's strawberry sorbet tonight!

Reply

Probably some of the best stuff I've ever made. Thank you, thank you!

Reply

This is similar to my lemon buttermilk sorbet. You can bet I'll be trying this. It's 100 here, perfect timing.

Reply

Made this recipe several times last summer and everyone who tried it LOVED it. Made an orange version and it was equally delicious. Not sure why I haven't made it yet THIS summer... eagerly awaiting arrival of ice cream maker recommended by food52!

Reply

Made a batch - delicious - and sandwiched it between two small sections of graham crackers for a mini key lime pie ice cream treat!

Img_1337_2 Reply

Brilliant! Have to try this.

Photo-1 Reply

I love this idea....I have to try it too....

Img_1879 Reply

looks delicious!

Winter2010 Reply

Made this last night...and I'm glad I did. It was delicious! This is a definite keeper, will be making this and variations of it all summer. Thanks merrill! :)

Reply

Oh, my. Thank you for this! Delicious ice cream! And 8 key limes made enough juice, then their juiceless outsides bobbed prettily in a pitcher of tea.

Img_1958 Reply

I just made a batch of this using my CSA tangerines - dreamy, creamsicle ice cream deliciousness!! Thanks, Merrill!

Img_1958 Reply

I forgot to add that to compensate for the sweeter fruit I used a little less sugar (2/3 cup) and a lot more juice (1 cup). YUM!

Picture_6 Reply

Is there a button for 'love' as opposed to 'like'? I made this last night and am obsessed. I'm going to make another batch using it as the filling for some ginger snap ice cream sandwiches and then another (only foregoing the freezing portion) using it as a whipped topping for a tart of some sort.

Reply

It is soooooo hot out and I sooooo can't wait to make this for company on Friday. Thanks for sharing.

Reply

Incredible! Thank you!

Ry_400 Reply

I made this over the weekend and brought it to a July 4th BBQ. It was delicious and a huge hit. One guy even said he died and went to lime ice cream heaven!

Newliztoqueicon-2 Reply

Sorry to go on and on but I have longed for this recipe - another 2 hours and dessert was served at the proper time - perfection! Regards to you and to your Mom aka Lauren Bacall, Liz

Newliztoqueicon-2 Reply

Your ice cream is pretty luscious with Meyer lemons! Posted a photo - started melting while my husband and buddy were begging for spoons... This is my new favorite ice cream recipe, thanks to you.

Newliztoqueicon-2 Reply

I disocvered I was out of white sugar, but powdered worked just fine - dissolved well.

Newliztoqueicon-2 Reply

Can't wait to try this with Meyer lemons tomorrow...So glad you added your hand-written recipe!

Meet our Hotliners:

Marion Nestle

Marion is the Paulette Goddard Professor of Nutrition, Food Studies, and Public Health at NYU and the author of several books on food policy, including Safe Food and What To Eat.