Recipe

Wet Bottom Shoofly Pie

Community Pick!

Wet Bottom Shoofly Pie

Photo 1 of 2
by Lizthechef

Wet Bottom Shoofly Pie

Photo 2 of 2
by Lizthechef

  • This recipe was entered in the contest for The Best Recipe or Technique Your Mother Taught You
  • A&M's Testing Notes: The sweet molasses custard is wonderful with the warm spices used in the topping. The technique of sprinkling the crumbs over the very wet filling results in a great pie with a gooey center...

    Expand Collapse
  • Chef

    Lizthechef's Notes: As a young bride from New York City transplanted to Lebanon, PA, my mother was slow to embrace Pennsylvania Dutch cooking. In culture shock, she couldn't even communicate with the landlord...

    Expand

Makes one pie

  1. Preheat oven to 400 degrees. Beat the egg yolk in a small bowl. Blend in the molasses. Add the boiling water once you have dissolved the soda in it. Set aside.

    Ask a question about this step
  2. Combine dry ingredients. Add butter and work into crumbs with your fingers. Pour liquid into pastry crust and evenly sprinkle crumbs on top.

    Ask a question about this step
  3. Bake for 10 minutes at 400 degrees, then lower heat to 325 degrees and bake for another 30 minutes. NOTE: If I had an 8 inch pie plate, I think it would be a better fit for the recipe, but this is how my mother wrote it out.

    Ask a question about this step

16 Comments on Wet Bottom Shoofly Pie

Kitchenaid Reply

This recipe fascinates me. I must try it!

Newliztoqueicon-2 Reply

Thanks, my husband is just home after a heart attack last Friday - he is doing better than I - let's talk...It's a simple recipe that works.

Kitchenaid Reply

What a scare! I'm glad he's doing well & you will soon, too.

Ab_sum Reply

Love the headnote as much as the recipe, if not more!!!

Reply

beautiful pie, great story.

Newliztoqueicon-2 Reply

Thank you, Stephanie. Today is my 60th birthday and you have given me a great gift by awarding my mother's shoofly pie an EP. A New Yorker, she would had gotten a big kick out of an award for a "Dutch" recipe.

Steve_dunn02 Reply

Wow, what a beautiful woman, and a great sounding recipe. I've never had shoofly before, I think it's time.

Newliztoqueicon-2 Reply

It's a simple recipe made easier if you buy the crusts that come in red boxes in the deli section of the grocery store. My Mom didn't like the taste of pie crust and neither do I - but don't tell anyone...;)

Dsc_0034 Reply

aw, i love this! i was actually thinking of posting my mom's shoo-fly pie too, but now will pick a different recipe. got to love the pennsylvania dutchy roots! glad to see you are in the wet bottom camp =)

Beer_and_pizza Reply

Shoofly pie is my favourite of all pies! Delighted to see someone else share the deliciousness of what is known, in our family, as "foofoo pie".

Newliztoqueicon-2 Reply

Thanks, everyone - this has been such an emotional day for me, and I know I'm not alone here...Maybe this Mother's Day will feel easier.

Winnie100 Reply

Shoofly pie completely fascinates me- yours looks delicious- and wow your mom was so stunning!

New_years_kitchen_hlc_only Reply

Okay, I simply must ask . . . did your mother also make Apple Pan Dowdy? Or did she ever mention it? I always associate the two . . . ;o)

Winnie100 Reply

I love apple pandowdy...I make it for Thanksgiving every year!

Img_1045_2 Reply

I love the photo! Your mother was so glamorous! The recipe looks fantastic and I'm putting it in my saved file right now.

Chocolate_peppermint_truffle_cookies_032 Reply

What a beautiful photograph of your mother. I'm so enjoying all the stories about our moms. What a gift this is to all of us this week. And I LOVE the recipe and have added it to my "to cook" list.

Meet our Hotliners:

victoriaspencer

Victoria is the Editors' Picks Editor of Food52.