Recipe

Three Onion Chowder with Parsleyed Oyster Crackers

Your Best Onion or Garlic Soup Contest Runner-up!

Three Onion Chowder with Parsleyed Oyster Crackers

Photo 1 of 3
by Sarah Shatz

Three Onion Chowder with Parsleyed Oyster Crackers

Photo 2 of 3
by Sarah Shatz

Three Onion Chowder with Parsleyed Oyster Crackers

Photo 3 of 3
by thirschfeld

Slideshow
  • This recipe was entered in the contest for Your Best Onion or Garlic Soup
  • A&M's Testing Notes: We'd argue that if you include the chives and garlic, this is really a five onion soup, but we're not going to quibble with thirschfeld who clearly knows how to make a great chowder. In additon...

    Expand Collapse
  • Chef

    thirschfeld's Notes: I really like chowders and really like French onion soup. I don't like pasty chowders so I didn't thicken it except for the starch released from the potatoes. One tip I learned from Jasper...

    Expand

Serves 4 to 6

  1. In a 3 quart Dutch oven or sauce pan add the butter and pancetta and place it over medium heat to render the pancetta. Once some of the fat has been released add the onions, shallot and celery. Saute until they are just becoming golden. You don't want them to brown too much or the soup will be brown. Add the leeks, garlic and thyme. Cook until the leeks are just becoming soft. Add the bay leaf and chicken stock. Bring it to a boil and add the half and half and the potatoes. Bring the soup back to a boil and then immediately turn off the heat and cover the pot. Allow it to rest for at least thirty minutes.

    Ask the hotline about this step!
  1. Heat a small saute pan over medium high heat. Add the butter and once it has stopped bubbling but is not brown, add the oyster crackers and toss the crackers to coat with the butter. Season with salt and pepper. Stir in the parsley and toss the crackers gently in order to coat all the crackers with the parsley. Pour out onto a baking sheet and let cool.

    Ask the hotline about this step!
  2. To finish the soup reheat it but don't let it boil. Taste a potato to check and see if it is done and adjust the seasoning if necessary. If the potatoes are not done then cook over low heat for 15 minutes. Stir in the parsley and chives and then ladle into cups or bowls. Top with a few oyster crackers and serve.

    Ask the hotline about this step!
Reply

Wow made this today and my partner and child loved it look forward to making more from this great site

Dscn0826 Reply

Oh great, I am glad you enjoyed it so much you plan to make it again. That makes my day, thank you.

Reply

Your wonderful recipe got rave reviews from my friends yesterday at lunch. It was great!! I made 2 small alterations: I used condensed skim instead of half and half (not great for the color but...) and added 1/4 inch diced butternut squash. Even better? Leftovers for tonight!
Thanks so much for sharing this with this rest of us -

Dscn0826 Reply

you are very welcome and I am glad you enjoyed it. I think your addition of butternut squash is great.

Reply

So I saw the picture and thought this chowder looked yummy. Read the ingredient list.... and instructions. Butter? Corn? Didn't see them listed.... hmm. Oh well, I know how to roll. Followed instructions, removed from heat,covered and let stand for 30 minutes. My potatoes were hard. Put back on the heat, and simmered another 30 minutes. Flavor was much better, potatoes still hard. 30 more minutes.... tender potatoes and Great flavor. My advice? Cook this soup longer than instructed for fully developed flavor. I bet it will taste even better the next day

Dscn0826 Reply

Sorry to hear about your potatoes. I have cooked this soup a lot, maybe over 50 times or more, and I have never had the potatoes remain hard but none the less I am sure it can happen. Seems like in the end you enjoyed the soup but I am sorry you had to go a round about way to get there.

Reply

Great recipe! I made it with fat free half & half, and added some small shrimp and it was wonderful. Thanks

Dscn0826 Reply

thank you, the shrimp would be nice.

Reply

Viewed this recipe on Huffington Post, which lured me to this fabulous site brimming with wonderful ideas and energy. So, I joined. How could I not? I made this chowder two nights ago with the addition of some leftover chunks of Oregon coast steelhead. Fragrant and luscious! And thanks so much for the 30 minutes off-the-heat tip after adding the potatoes. The texture was perfect! I'll use this technique for chowder from now on.

Dscn0826 Reply

Thank you and I am so glad you like it. Salmon would be to great

Reply

I just made this for a few friends as a part of a "pre" thanksgiving meal. They all loved it. In fact, my friend just told me it was her favorite part of the meal! I didn't even add the chives or parsley at the end because I didn't see that the last paragraph under the cracker menu was meant for the soup - but it was still delicious!

Thanks for the great recipe - this was a great fall soup that didn't require a food processor, which was my only stipulation of the night.

Dscn0826 Reply

Thank you and you are welcome. I am so glad everyone enjoyed it

Reply

I made this on Saturday and had it for dinner tonight. It was terrific with a lovely balance.

Lnd_jen Reply

This was tonight's dinner, and it was really delicious. Since I didn't see the butter listed in the ingredient listing for the chowder, though it appeared in the first step, I winged it and used what we like to call "a knob" :D Also pulled the pancetta out after it crisped to add back in right before serving. The best pancetta we can reliably get here is La Quercia, and it's pre-sliced very thin. Absolutely wonderful recipe, and thank you for sharing it!

Dscn0826 Reply

I am so glad you liked it. An yes I often use a "knob" of butter. That might be my favorite recipe measurement. Yeah I never know about the crispy bacon/pancetta question. I don't like it crunchy but I know lots of others do so I am glad you made it how you like it.

Picture_11 Reply

I love chowders but I don't like them heavy, either. This looks luscious, thank you for sharing.

Imag0055 Reply

Frustrated by the limitations of a small town grocery store?
Bacon, diced finely, makes a perfectly good substitute for pancetta.
No shallots? Add some more onion or leeks.
Scallops, added to the hot soup to poach just before serving---delicious.
(Little Maine shrimp, now in season, would probably be good, too.)

Reply

How great to have a chowder recipe that really has onions take center stage. A nice change from usual onion broth soups. Hearty, but not heavy.

Reply

Malpec oysters that is.

Reply

I agree with Antonia. This is very similar to my husbands fish chowder with scallops but after we read this he said he would just add fresh Malpec (small and sweet) just at the end when it is resting.

Dscn0826 Reply

I really like that everyone is taking an idea an running with it. So cool. But what is really great is getting to watch the slide show and seeing Amanda and Merrill make my recipe. So so cool. Thanks for all the great compliments too.

Img_1045_2 Reply

Just love this soup. I have absolutely everything in the house, too! I see this appearing at our dinner table before the end of the weekend. Thank you for posting!

Food52_photo Reply

Yes, this is really gorgeous. So glad you are here thirschfeld.

New_years_kitchen_hlc_only Reply

I'm SO glad this is a finalist! I made this early this week, using natural bacon instead of pancetta (because that's all I had), and using 2% milk instead of half and half, because we prefer a somewhat lighter soup. I did, however, use about two teaspoons of butter when first cooking the onions, after pouring off most of the bacon fat. I removed the bacon, too, adding the chopped pieces it at the end, so that it is crisp, but I can see how cooking with the pancetta would add to the flavor of the soup, so I plan to try this with pancetta, as instructed here. Also, as Mrs. Larkin noted, a rich, flavorful chicken broth makes all the difference.

Newliztoqueicon-2 Reply

I love recipes that use simple ingred. most cooks have on hand. Brilliant re the oyster crackers. Sunday supper coming up - thanks for a guaranteed addition to my recipe box!

Mrs Reply

Really love this one, and that it uses chicken stock. Calling all roast chicken carcasses!

Chocolate_peppermint_truffle_cookies_032 Reply

This looks fabulous and was a great pick for finalist. I love fish chowders but never make them anymore since my husband is allergic to all non-shellfish, so this is a great way to reconstruct those wonderful chowders. I can't wait to make this one. Thanks and good luck!

New_years_kitchen_hlc_only Reply

You could put some scallops in this and it would be tasty, I bet. I use virtually the same recipe (though I cook the potato in the broth and aromatics, before adding the milk) and then at the last minute, right before eating, add bite-sized chunks of cod just to cook them. Be sure to use great stock, though, or the soup won't be nearly as good. It makes a great winter time dinner soup.

Chocolate_peppermint_truffle_cookies_032 Reply

Great idea Antonia! Scallops are definitely on his menu. Thanks! I'm thinking I'll make this on Sunday for us.

Lnd_jen Reply

This has finalist written all over it :) Can't wait to make this - the crackers are a wonderful addition.

New_years_kitchen_hlc_only Reply

Gorgeous! I can almost smell it, just reading the ingredients. I had fish chowder -- made very much as you've made this one, but adding fish and a bit of (my own) frozen corn -- on my dance card this week, but I believe that's going to change. You're so right about letting the chowder sit for a while. That usually happens at my house by default, but now that you mention it, I'm going to build that into my schedule henceforth. Thank you for posting this! It's perfectly lovely.

Meet our Hotliners:

Shuna Lydon

How_to_make_a_custard_part_1

Shuna is the Pastry Chef at Peels Restaurant in NYC and author of the acclaimed blog Eggbeater.

Shuna Lydon answered A question about a recipe: Chocolate Dump-It Cake about 1 month ago