Recipe Trophy

Lemon Posset

Wildcard Contest Winner!

Lemon Posset

Photo 1 of 5
by Sarah Shatz

Lemon Posset

Photo 2 of 5
by mrslarkin

Lemon Posset

Photo 3 of 5
by Lizthechef

Lemon Posset

Photo 4 of 5
by Panfusine

Lemon Posset

Photo 5 of 5
by mrslarkin

  • A&M's Testing Notes: This recipe is a wonder of science. It's the perfect thing for anyone who may be fearful of making custard but harbors a weakness -- as we do -- for this sort of milky, comforting, nursery...

    Expand Collapse
  • Chef

    mrslarkin's Notes: I’ve been intrigued by Lemon Posset recipes for a while now. In Ye Olde English days of yore, it was a milk drink thickened with wine. My Posset recipe is so simple, as they all are, really...

    Expand

Serves 4

  1. In a small saucepan, heat cream and sugar to boiling, stirring to dissolve sugar. Continue boiling for 5 minutes. Watch the heat - don’t let the cream boil over.

    Ask the hotline about this step!
  2. Remove pan from heat and stir in lemon juice. Let cool, about 15 minutes.

    Ask the hotline about this step!
  3. Pour even amounts into four ramekins. Refrigerate at least 2 hours, or until set.

    Ask the hotline about this step!
  4. Serve with unsweetened whipped cream, or shortbread cookies to dunk.

    Ask the hotline about this step!
Reply

Served this with fresh berries on top-- simple, beautiful and so tasty!

Mrs Reply

thanks for letting me know currypaste. Glad you liked it!

Reply

This is ridiculously easy and amazingly delicious. Thank you!

Mrs Reply

Yay! You're welcome, willsmom. So glad you like it!

Food54_profile_pic Reply

Great recipe! So simple and elegant--thanks for sharing. I tweaked it for lime and wrote about it on my blog.
http://stillsimmering.wordpress.com/2012/01/09/savoring-the-moment-backyard-adventures-sweet-lime-posset/

Mrs Reply

Thanks, Ms. T! So glad you enjoyed this. Really great blog post. Savor, indeed. Happy new year to you.

Food54_profile_pic Reply

Thanks--happy new year to you also! It really was the perfect dessert to go with crab and champagne :)

Img_0391 Reply

Fantastic! I'll never make lemon mousse again...so easy! I used meyer lemons and added about 1 tsp of zest with the juice. Served with gingersnaps (the thin crispy variety.) Wished there were some left over for breakfast. Will make more next time! Thanks for this incredible sweet treat.

Mrs Reply

You're welcome, deanna1001! So glad you enjoyed it.

Img_0391 Reply

Fantastic! I'll never make lemon mousse again...so easy! I used meyer lemons and added about 1 tsp of zest with the juice. Served with gingersnaps (the thin crispy variety.) Wished there were some left over for breakfast. Will make more next time! Thanks for this incredible sweet treat.

Reply

Delicious. Perfect. Eating some right now =)

Mrs Reply

that's wonderful, kiki-bee!! Thanks for letting me know.

Me Reply

We had this last night at the FOOD52 Cookbook launch party in Manhattan -- totally YUM!!!!

Mrs Reply

woo hoo! Yeah, i saw that on the @citygrit twitter feed! How very exciting! They looked so cute in the little mason jars!

Mrs Reply

Here's an awesome adaptation of the Posset recipe: http://www.biggirlssmallkitchen.com/2011/09/amazingly-easy-rich-lemon-tart.html

Reply

Wow! How could something so simple be so delicious? Thank you for introducing me to this. Fantastic. I like my lemon desserts extra lemony, so added some zest. Will be trying this with limes next time.
Thank you again. This really is better living through chemistry.

Mrs Reply

Yay! So glad you enjoyed this, drkate! Let me know how the lime works out.

2007-09-11e-s4 Reply

I made this a couple nights ago for the San Ignacio Art League that met yesterday. Most all of the ladies in the canyon meet at my sister's cabin every Thursday and sometimes on Sunday just to get away from their menfolks and enjoy the estrogem-rich atmosphere. To that end, I usually put together some sort of sweet treat for Sis to serve them. I try not to repeat the treat, so am always on the lookout for sweets that are not too time- or labor intensive. How in the world could one beat 3 ingredients and about 5 minutes?! I did make some of my ginger cookies to go along with this and every single person gave this recipe a gold star. (Well, okay - one of the ladies was out of town visiting her grandchildren and another had some ranch work that just had to get done, so there were only 3 ladies there....but they all loved it!) thanks, mrslarkin!

Mrs Reply

Thank you WileyP! You have made my whole summer! P.S. got your note :) Will right back when i get a morsel of time.

Newliztoqueicon-2 Reply

Isn't this great?! It's a good thing I keep a journal of who I feed what at dinner parties because this is dessert year round at our house...

Ozoz_profile Reply

Making this now.....used fine Caribbean brown sugar instead of the white and upped the lemonny flavours with microplaned zest. Excited and thanking God its almost bed time....so I can wake up to a pot!

Mrs Reply

Sounds delish KB! How goes the move? Are you done unpacking?

Img_2764 Reply

Somehow this got past me the first time. Going to try it this week. The texture looks lovely.

Mrs Reply

thanks, boulangere. this is one of my favorites. Let me know how it turns out for you!

John-george-brown-xx-eating-the-profits-1878 Reply

I like the simplicity of this. I would like to ask if cream is necessary for the setting, or if it is used for the creaminess. If I attempt making making is with whole milk, would I end up with ricotta instead? Thank you. :)

John-george-brown-xx-eating-the-profits-1878 Reply

Ops, fast typing and you get typos. Making making is = making it.

Mrs Reply

Thanks, Droplet. I'm pretty certain the amount of fat in the cream is the main player here. I've never tried it with whole milk. But if you do, please let us know how it turns out!

Reply

Made this last night for a dinner party. Followed your suggestion of topping it with unsweetened whipped cream, also added a couple of raspberries for color. Made some key lime shortbread to go along with it. It was all delicious!! A very nice way to finish our meal - creamy and light. Thank you for sharing a wonderful recipe!

Mrs Reply

You are very welcome, Meg! That's so great to hear! Love this with berries, and your shortbread sounds fantastic!

20071208_cru_themomma_7027 Reply

soooooooo delicious and very rich... i just ate way too much ;-(

Mrs Reply

So glad you liked it! Yep, this one's good in moderation! ;-)

036 Reply

How funny - we made it too! We has ginger snaps and coconut cookies with it - delicious!!!!

Mrs Reply

Yay, aargersi! Glad you enjoyed it - sounds extra yummy with cookies. :)

036 Reply

Also good the next day with blueberries if you happen to have one left over :-)

Mrs Reply

oh, good to know!! Love lemon/blueberry combo.

Lobster_001 Reply

Oh mrslarkin...I made this last night for dessert and it was delicious! The flavor and texture were so delicate. We plan to make it again soon. Thanks!

Mrs Reply

That's great, nannydeb! I'm so glad you liked it!!

Katherine_photo Reply

I know I'm late to this party, but I just made this recipe and had to tell you how amazing it is! It could not have been easier (although my cream totally overboiled, but I think I've got the hang of it for next time) and the result is just pure joy. My kind of dessert. I added in some lemon zest as well. Oh, and I tried it topped with fresh passion fruit seeds - holy moly, what a divine combination. Thanks for sharing this recipe!

Mrs Reply

That is so great to hear, kmartinelli! You are very welcome. Easy, delicious recipes are a joy, aren't they? Your passion fruit addition sounds killer!! I'm trying that next time. Thanks for the idea!

Img_2895 Reply

Very lovely dessert, especially with Meyer lemons and their zest. The 'setting up' comes from the interaction between the cream and the acidity of the lemon juice.

Mrs Reply

Thank you so much, romano!

186003_1004761561_1198459_n Reply

If you go to your profile, there is a box to check whether or not you want to be notified if someone comments on a recipe that you have commented on or they have commented on your recipe...you will get a lot of emails! You can also check whether or not you want to be connected to twitter...so when you vote it shows up on twitter or when you post a new recipe. If it doesn't work...notify food 52...they are very talented at solving these problems with the site.

Mrs Reply

thanks, dymnyno. But for some reason, having the box checked doesn't work for some people, including me. I think I'll try with my gmail account, like ChezSuzanne did below.

Newliztoqueicon-2 Reply

Your life-saving recipe is on deck as dessert following a seafood gratin this weekend. So easy and who has time to make a complicated dessert for a dinner party?!

Mrs Reply

So nice to hear that, Liz! This is a PERFECT dinner party dessert. Sorry for delay in responding! Wish I knew when I get comments - I don't get notices so have to scroll thru all my recipes occasionally.

Chocolate_peppermint_truffle_cookies_032 Reply

I had the same problem for the longest time. I solved it by opening a gmail account. Now I get notified when someone comments on my recipe, or comments to a thread I commented on. Soooo much easier now - I used to have to do exactly what you describe.

Mrs Reply

Thanks, ChezSuzanne, I think I will try with my gmail account!!

Chocolate_peppermint_truffle_cookies_032 Reply

I hope it works for you like it did for me! I too had checked all the boxes. The food52 folks said it likely had to do with the privacy settings on my comcast email account. Good luck!!!

Mrs Reply

Yay! It worked! Someone send me a message on my profile page, please - I want to see if that works, too!! This is so exciting!

Chocolate_peppermint_truffle_cookies_032 Reply

Just sent you a message, Liz! Mission accomplished??

Mrs Reply

yahooo!!! it works!! Got your message! Thanks so much, ChezSuzanne!! What a relief!

Chocolate_peppermint_truffle_cookies_032 Reply

Yah!!!! It honestly felt like it changed my life! So I completely understand.

Morgan3x5bw Reply

This was - to use an over used term - sublime. Kids and adults enjoyed it, and all asked for seconds. Thank you for sharing it, it will be going in to the repertoire.

Mrs Reply

Wow, I am so happy to hear that, SOE. Thanks for the kind words!

Newliztoqueicon-2 Reply

I'd forgotten how much I wanted to try this out, me being such a Myer lemon lover. It was so good last weekend that my husband and I ate one in the afternoon before our dinner guest arrived. This is probably one of the top three favorites from year one at food 52 for this home cook! ps mrslarkin asked me to publish my quick, informal photo that I tweeted to her...

Mrs Reply

Thanks, Liz! So glad you enjoyed it! The photo looks great, too!

Cropjah Reply

This is one of my favorite go-to desserts. I serve it in stemmed crystal wine glasses with a dab of whipped cream a few berries and mint. Looks as elegant as it tastes.

Mrs Reply

jhagye, that sounds beautiful!!

Reply

Can you use other flavors in this recipe or only lemon???

Mrs Reply

You can probably use other flavors WITH the lemon juice, like lime or orange - but I think only lemon juice contains the acid necessary to set the custard. So I would probably not replace the lemon juice entirely with something else.

Henrykiss Reply

mrslarkin! did you see your posset was featured in the kitchn? so fun! http://www.thekitchn.com/thekitchn/ingredients-dairy/possets-the-simplest-custard-ever-115030

Mrs Reply

OMG! I did not! Let me go see...

Gaby_by_sarah Reply

This lemon posset is stand-alone delicious but also so versatile! I baked some lemon cupcakes, cut a little well out of the middle of each baked cake, filled them with the chilled posset, and then topped each one with lightly sweetened whipped cream and a berry. They were sooooooo good!

Mrs Reply

Wow! I'm so glad you enjoyed this recipe, Gabriela! Sorry for the delay - I just noticed your comment today. Your adaptation sounds fantastic!!!!

N94600339_30363046_1613 Reply

Mrs. Larkin- Do you think I could pour this into a tart crust and it would set up the same? I love the idea of this INSIDE a shortbread crust....

Mrs Reply

I haven’t ever put it in a crust. But that sounds really nice! The inner, closer-to-the-bottom part of the posset is looser than the top, so I’m wondering if chilling it in a flatter, tart-like shell will produce a uniformly-firmer curd. Also, not sure if the pre-baked tart shell will soak up the liquid and get soggy.

N94600339_30363046_1613 Reply

Excellent - was definitely thinking of par-baking. I'll try it soon and let you know how it works!

N94600339_30363046_1613 Reply

It worked! I made a shortbread crust, par-baked it, and when it was cool, spread a thin layer of white chocolate-almond gianduja in the center (I thought it would act as a buffer to keep the posset from absorbing into the crust), and once the chocolate was set, poured the posset over the top. It was delicious - though it was equally good in the ramekins I made also!

Mrs Reply

aptcooker: that is awesome! So glad it turned out. Will definitely try your adaptation!

Dscn0826 Reply

I have been looking at this and can't wait to make it.

Mrs Reply

Oh, thanks, thirschfeld. I hope you like it!

Img_0828 Reply

congratulations! This looks wonderful!

Mrs Reply

Thank you so much, Jennifer Ann!

Reply

I dream of a yard full of lemon trees - that's how lemon-obsessed I am. I particularly love recipes that are really elemental in their lemon-ness – with few ingredients to mask or compete with the pure flavor…the simplest tart filling, ice cream, even homemade limoncello. So this recipe is right up my lemon alley – must try it. (And could I possibly have used the word lemon any more in one comment?)

Mrs Reply

Glad you like the recipe, amysarah! Your passion for lemons is inspiring! You’re in good company in this morsel of the blogosphere.

Mrs Reply

Just wondering who's reflection that is in the spoon. Any guesses?

Img_0423 Reply

Love the reflection. That is great. congrats on your recipe being selected!

Mrs Reply

Thank you so much, cwfg!!

Mrs Reply

I mean, cfwg!! :-)

Ry_400 Reply

This sounds right up my alley - lemony and easy! Can't wait to try it. Congrats!

Mrs Reply

Thanks, melissav! Yes, easy-peasy! My favorite kind!

Steve_dunn02 Reply

Yes, the old boiling over risk....sure to happen to me even if I'm staring right at the pot when it erupts. Oh well, sounds like a perfectly acceptable risk for such a great sounding recipe. Congrats on your win, Mrslarkin!

Mrs Reply

Thanks, Chef ! There are times when I am thankful I have a flat-top range. ;-)

Lnd_jen Reply

Wow, I don't usually go for dessert-y things, but I am a huge fan of lemon, and this sounds fabulous. Congrats on your win - what a great addition to the book!

Mrs Reply

Thank you, LND!!! I think lemons might be the most versatile ingredient ever.

Food52_photo Reply

Yes, this rocks, as the (old uncool) kids say. Lemons make me swoon, cream makes me swoon. I have never heard of posset. Glad to learn something, yet again. Congrats!

Mrs Reply

Thanks so much, ENunn!

Chocolate_peppermint_truffle_cookies_032 Reply

This is a perfect addition to the book! I saved it to my recipes when I first saw it but got distracted with other things. I'm making this today and topping it with some strawberries I saw at the market. A well-deserved congrats!

Mrs Reply

Thank you, ChezSuzanne! Let me know how it turns out!

Lobster_001 Reply

Congratulations! I can't wait to try this.

Mrs Reply

Thanks, nannydeb! Hope you like it!

Ashtaco Reply

this is a great addition to the book! congrats! i LOVE lemon curd, so I can't wait to try this!

Mrs Reply

Thanks, wanderash! I hope you like it!

Ap5 Reply

Congratulations, mrslarkin! I can't wait to try this.

Mrs Reply

Thanks, ying! Right back at ya!

036 Reply

CONGRATS! This is such a great recipe ... in little shells with a berry or two on top this spring / summer is in the plan !!!

Mrs Reply

Oh, that sounds so nice! Thanks, aargersi!

Henrykiss Reply

congratulations! this looks delightful!

Mrs Reply

Thanks, arielleclementine! (I love saying, and typing, your name.)

New_years_kitchen_hlc_only Reply

Love it, love it, love it!! Plan to make this ASAP. Congrats MrsLarkin!!

Mrs Reply

Thank you so much, AntoniaJames!

Monkeys Reply

Yay! Congratulations! I've been thinking about this recipe ever since I saw it first posted. It is fascinating.

Mrs Reply

Wowee! Thanks so much monkeymom!

Newliztoqueicon-2 Reply

This sounds delicious - I have a bowl of Meyer lemons sitting on the counter - here comes dessert...Thumbs up and thank you!

Mrs Reply

Thanks Lizthechef! Oh, Meyer lemons - you lucky girl! Let me know how it turns out!

Chocolate_peppermint_truffle_cookies_032 Reply

I agree-very intriguing that 3 ingredients prepared so simply would result in such a tasty dessert. I can't wait to try this one. What's great about this recipe is that these are ingredients I always have on hand! Thanks!!

Mrs Reply

Thanks, ChezSuzanne! Me too - makes me happy when I have all the ingredients for a dish!

Mrs Reply

Thanks dymnyno! I'm currently reading the Donna Hay cookbooks. Beautiful photos and easy-peasy recipes.

186003_1004761561_1198459_n Reply

Very intriguing recipe!! Iam with you when it comes to recipes that are simple and creative without too many ingredients or convoluted methods.

Meet our Hotliners:

Melissa Clark

Melissa Clark is a food columnist for the New York Times and has written over 32 cookbooks, including the recent Cook This Now.

Melissa Clark answered Runny pumpkin pie about 1 month ago