Although their French neighbors are more renowned for having a deft touch with pastry, the Italians have come up with a surprising number of winning desserts over the years: tiramisu, crostatas, gelato, panna cotta, biscotti, cannoli, zabaglione, semifreddo, tartufo. So, pick your poison and submit your best Italian...
These are not your usual contests. We have a slightly nutty system but it works. Together, the Food52 community has created two cookbooks this way -- there’s no stopping us now. Read about it
Read about it »
photo 1 of 19
Starting at the top: saffron, egg yolk, hazelnuts, heavy cream, cardamom, lemon, sugar, dried cherries, white wine, honey and sweet vermouth.
photo 2 of 19
Saffron messing up the yolks' clean and tidy look.
photo 3 of 19
photo 4 of 19
First we began with the semifreddo base, whisking together the yolks, sugar and saffron.
photo 5 of 19
Next, Merrill whipped the mixture over a double boiler -- a good workout, if you're looking for one.
photo 6 of 19
This is the consistency you're looking for -- it gets elastic and sticky.
photo 7 of 19
To make the cherry sauce, you combine dried cherries, sugar, toasted cardamom, wine, and lemon juice in a pan, then boil it down to a syrup. (To toast cardamom, a step we resisted but were later glad to have done, we spread the ground spice in a small pan and placed it over medium-low heat until we could smell the cardamom.)
photo 8 of 19
In goes the wine.
photo 9 of 19
Brenna warns you that the egg yolk mixture will be sticky but we didn't expect it to be this sticky. Here, we ponder starting over, but then decide we'll forge ahead, and we're glad we did because the mixture loosened as soon as vermouth was added.
photo 10 of 19
See just how sticky it was!
photo 11 of 19
Here, sweet vermouth performs its magic.
photo 12 of 19
Whipped cream -- what's not to love!
photo 13 of 19
Merrill folds the cream and yolk mixtures together.
photo 14 of 19
photo 15 of 19
You'll probably use 4 ramekins of the same size and color -- here, we've given ourselves 4 alternative dishes for the finished dish photo. Which one will it be?
photo 16 of 19
Freezer time: yes, Amanda likes to mix her chocolate and mint ice creams. And no, that frozen pink lemonade isn't something she'd usually buy -- it was for a recipe test for the Times. And lechef, that's your Zesty Herbed Chicken Broth on the right, beneath the pie doughs.
photo 17 of 19
The hazelnuts, dressed with olive oil, honey and salt, before toasting in the oven.
photo 18 of 19
Here, we make it pretty for its close-up!
photo 19 of 19
photo 1 of 17
photo 2 of 17
Amanda is very precise with her flour measuring.
photo 3 of 17
Just a little butter to make sure the crust is crisp...
photo 4 of 17
An egg to bind the dough.
photo 5 of 17
Be careful not to overmix the dough -- you want the dry and wet ingredients to just barely come together.
photo 6 of 17
When you pinch the dough between your fingers, it should just stick to itself.
photo 7 of 17
If your ricotta is especially watery, make sure to drain it for several hours before making the filling. Ours needed minimal draining.
photo 8 of 17
Amanda combines milk and rice in a cast iron pot; it will simmer until the rice is tender, and the milk has thickened.
photo 9 of 17
This is a lovely, workable dough.
photo 10 of 17
We used a smaller pie plate (9') and ended up with leftover dough -- which we dusted with cinnamon sugar and baked on its own, producing a delicious snack to get us through the afternoon!
photo 11 of 17
Once the rice is cooked, Food Blogga has you cool it. We used an ice bath to speed up the process.
photo 12 of 17
7 eggs get beaten with 1 cup of sugar and some lemon juice and zest (or extract). We used Meyer lemon juice and zest.
photo 13 of 17
photo 14 of 17
Amanda adds some vanilla -- what fun!
photo 15 of 17
After we whisk in the drained ricotta, it's time for the rice.
photo 16 of 17
We had leftover filling because of our small pie shell, so we baked the rest by itself in a dish.
photo 17 of 17
